..off my cuff… if it doesn’t make sense, then by all means let me know :-)
I’ll start off by quoting something I saw on Marc Canter’s site:
HHhmmmm – it seems like the world needs a standard for extending RSS with topics…. that are compatible with RDF and XTM. Bitzi could use it, Joi could proselytize it, we’ll build a front-end for it, Ross could analyze it’s social capital, and Doc could blog it. Amd Howard will report in from the Helsinki Burger King what the mob thinks. Another hot new meme. HHhmmmmmmma
This led me to check out TopicExchange.com, which has a page that makes a heroic attempt to corral Technology topics
I say “heroic” for a reason. I think we all benefit from seeing thinly sliced info-nuggets tucked away in categories. I also think there’s at least as many ways to define categories or topics as there are people. Indeed, over the course of a couple of minutes, I may come up with several different ways to think of the Sex Pistols:
- /music/punk/SexPistols
- /uk/england/1977/movements/punks/SexPistols
- /entrepreneurs/MalcolmMcLaren/SexPistols
and so on… For many people, the first example of /music/punk/SexPistols is the most obvious. But then, music is easy to categorize, compared to other topics with more dimensions (Film, for one…) Think of groups of people, and how they consume/peruse categories. As the group gets larger, and the number of categories increases, the potential for confusion (“oh, I wouldn’t have put English Cooking under Gourmet Cuisine”) skyrockets.
Which leads me back to what Marc said.
Categorization, topics, etc. where items are only assigned to one path are somewhat weakened in any context that extends further than a particular domain, clique, niche, or other form of “group”. So much depends on why someone is searching for something.. what is their context?
Context is everything.
Keywords are more flexible. Masses of keywords imply a multitude of relevant categories. General and Specific keywords give rise to the idea of self-organizing categories. Let’s go back to the Sex Pistols example. Let’s say I post a web page about the song “God Save The Queen”. I might use these keywords:
Queen, England, SexPistol, 1977, Punk, Music, MalcolmMcLaren
A number of paths spring out this grouping of keywords. Some of them even make sense! (1977/England/Queen/Punk would show SexPistol as a node)
To wind up, I am saying that getting large groups of people to agree on any fixed way of representing Topics or Categories is problematic. I am also saying that a method of taking groups of well-chosen keywords makes it much easier to find things by context. I would love to hear about a project that goes after the problem of “organizing category paths out of keywords”.